top of page

Debunking the Myth: Cutting Nails Straight Prevents Ingrown Toenails


Bare feet in Grey Sand surrounded by sea shells

One of the most prevalent misconceptions in foot care is that cutting toenails straight across is a surefire way to prevent ingrown toenails. While this technique is part of good nail care, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Many other factors influence the development of ingrown toenails, and understanding these will help you better prevent and treat the condition.


Understanding Ingrown Toenails

An ingrown toenail occurs when the edge or corner of a toenail grows into the surrounding skin, causing pain, redness, swelling, and sometimes infection. The big toe is most commonly affected, though it can happen to any toenail.


The pain from an ingrown toenail ranges from mild discomfort to severe tenderness, especially when wearing shoes or putting pressure on the affected toe. Left untreated, ingrown toenails can lead to infection, resulting in pus or fluid discharge, and in extreme cases, they may require surgical intervention.


Why Cutting Nails Straight Isn’t Enough

While cutting toenails straight is an essential step to reduce the chances of ingrown toenails, it is only part of the bigger picture. Here’s why:


1. Nail Length:

It’s not just the shape of the cut that matters—length is also crucial. Trimming nails too short, even straight across, can encourage the skin to fold over the nail, leading the edge to penetrate the skin as it grows back. It’s recommended to cut nails just enough that the corners don’t grow into the skin but remain slightly above the nail bed.


2. Footwear:

Improperly fitting shoes are one of the biggest causes of ingrown toenails. Shoes that are too tight or have a narrow toe box place excessive pressure on the toenails, forcing them into the surrounding skin. The toenails, in response to this pressure, can start growing inward. Shoes with a wide toe box and enough room for toes to move freely can reduce this risk.


3. Repetitive Trauma:

People involved in sports or activities that cause frequent pressure on their feet, like running, soccer, or dancing, are more susceptible to ingrown toenails. This repetitive stress can cause micro-injuries to the nail, changing its growth pattern and leading to ingrowth.


4. Genetics:

Some individuals have naturally more curved toenails or thick nails that grow downward, increasing their likelihood of developing ingrown toenails, even with proper cutting techniques. If you’re genetically predisposed, you may need additional measures, such as more frequent monitoring and care, to avoid ingrown toenails.


Comprehensive Nail Care to Prevent Ingrown Toenails

Taking care of your toenails goes beyond just the shape in which you cut them. A more holistic approach ensures better prevention:


1. Proper Trimming Technique:

Always use sharp, clean nail clippers, and cut the nails straight across. Leave a small amount of white nail at the tip (about 1-2 mm) to ensure the nail edge doesn’t dig into the skin. Avoid rounding the edges, as this promotes the nail to grow inward.

   

2. Foot Soaks Before Cutting:

If your nails are thick or hard to cut, soaking your feet in warm, soapy water for 10-15 minutes softens both the nails and the skin around them. This makes trimming safer and easier, reducing the risk of uneven cuts.


3. Wear Proper Footwear:

Ensure that your shoes provide enough space for your toes to move freely. Tight or pointy shoes, especially those worn for long periods, squeeze your toes and make ingrown toenails more likely. Look for shoes with a wide toe box and avoid those that press the toes together.


4. Foot Hygiene:

Keeping your feet clean and dry can prevent infections. Regular washing, especially in warm and humid conditions, helps maintain nail and skin health. Moisturizing the feet also prevents the skin from becoming dry and hard, reducing the chances of the nail cutting into it.


5. Prevent Trauma:

Be mindful of activities that put excessive pressure on your toes, such as running, playing soccer, or hiking. If you engage in sports or wear shoes with high impact on your feet, consider using padded socks or special insoles that provide extra support to protect your nails.


What to Do When You Have an Ingrown Toenail

Despite taking precautions, ingrown toenails can still occur. Early treatment is crucial to prevent the condition from worsening:


1. Home Treatment:

Soak your foot in warm water for 15-20 minutes, several times a day. This softens the area around the ingrown nail, reducing swelling and relieving pain. After soaking, try gently lifting the nail away from the skin with a small piece of clean cotton or dental floss, placing it underneath the edge to guide the nail as it grows.


2. Over-the-Counter Medications:

Topical antibiotic ointments can prevent infections and help manage minor cases. Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) like ibuprofen can reduce pain and swelling.


3. Seek Medical Help:

If the condition worsens or doesn’t improve with home remedies, it’s time to see a podiatrist. They may perform a procedure called partial nail avulsion, where part of the ingrown nail is removed to relieve pressure and pain. In severe or recurring cases, they might recommend a matrixectomy, where the nail bed (matrix) is destroyed to prevent regrowth of the ingrown portion.


Chronic Ingrown Toenails and Permanent Solutions

For those who suffer from chronic ingrown toenails—either due to genetics, injury, or severe deformity—a more permanent solution may be required. A total or partial nail avulsion can be performed, where part or all of the nail is removed, along with the root, to prevent the problem from recurring. This procedure is often done under local anesthesia, and while recovery takes a few weeks, it effectively eliminates the issue.


The Complete Picture

Cutting toenails straight across is a helpful strategy but is only one piece of the puzzle in preventing ingrown toenails. Factors such as shoe choice, genetics, nail length, and trauma to the nail all contribute to the development of this condition. To truly reduce your risk of ingrown toenails, you must adopt a comprehensive approach that includes proper trimming, good footwear, and attentive nail care. By understanding and addressing all the contributing factors, you can maintain healthy, pain-free feet and avoid the discomfort of ingrown toenails.


Comments


bottom of page